An individual’s gender identity is expressed within the boundaries of societal institutions that shape social interaction, such as family, education, and healthcare. A person’s ability to access, capitalize on, and receive social support through society’s institutions has the power to influence their chosen gender expression. Within the United States, discrimination and stereotyping of Black and Latinx Americans has re-emerged due to pre-existing bias. These stereotypes are now governing the range of permissible, or accepted, gender expressions within Black and Latinx communities entirely. Such institutional racism leads to a set of sociologically unique experiences, which include navigating social expectations that are more illusive than those faced by other groups. Failure to grasp the social context of illusive and ever-changing expectations can result in limited access to citizen relief efforts, thus furthering one’s limited ability to develop a secure gender identity. Intersectionality of race and gender in societal institutions creates a juxtaposition laden with racial and gendered expectations, which can determine what one’s identity becomes, and how one chooses to convey that identity to others over time.
The distinct difficulties met by underrepresented groups requires a sociological approach which highlights the importance of multifaceted identities. Intersectionality encourages individuals to reflect on how facets of their identity, such as gender, influence their lived experiences and intrapersonal relationships. As stated by The University of Massachusetts at Amherst, “An intersectional perspective examines how identities are related to each other in our own experiences and how the social structures of race, class, gender, sexuality, age, and ability intersect for everyone,” thus encouraging individuals to address how socially constructed discrimination affects their identity expression. Intersectionality does more than simply recognize how multiple identities influence one’s behaviors and expectations in social settings. It challenges the individual to confront the presence of social biases, which are related to their distinct social identities, within their communities. The University of Amherst describes, “...notions of gender and the way a person’s gender is interpreted by others, are always impacted by notions of race and the way that person’s race is interpreted,” which underlines how possessing multiple identities can create a layered social experience, which is deeply influenced by institutional oppression that affects one or more facets of one’s identity.
Black and Latinx individuals frequently experience the consequences of limited equity, which has historically resulted in demonizing those who do not adhere to social values that require submission to consistent dehumanization. As young Black and Latinx men mature, the societal policing of their gender expression results in limited opportunity for emotional or psychological support from citizen support efforts in the event they have not yet conformed. According to the American Academy of Political and Social Science:
“Gender, like race, is always determined by specific contexts. In
this case, the criminalization of Black and Latino males and the
criminal justice system's expectations of masculinity provide
young men with gender resources that often limit their life
chances and channel them deeper into the racialized and
gendered criminal justice system.”
Intersectionality should always be used to address and examine the violence perpetrated by institutions through their norms and practices, as this framework emphasizes how institutions converge social identities to influence social experiences. In this way, the gap in the understanding of the criminal's justice system can be seen in how some groups are disenfranchised by inflexible, set standards. This reality is often harsh, as limited opportunities to experience joy without the permission of others creates distance between one’s expression of self and one’s community. This form of emotional exclusion is propagated by the criminal justice system as a means of encouraging Black and Latinx youth to submit to the expectations of a structurally discriminatory system, and gender ideology. These expectations not only serve to distance an individual from themselves, and their community, but also do little to prepare young men for the realities of life in many marginalized communities. According to the American Academy of Political and Social Science:
“Mainstream society and the criminal justice system expect a
masculine conformity that emphasizes hard work, law abidance,
and an acceptance of subordinate social positions. Some young
men attempt to embrace this masculinity as a means to reform.
However, when they attempt to follow these expectations, they
come to realize that doing so does not allow for survival on the
streets, a place to which they can always expect to return.”
Society’s inability to maintain positive perceptions of Black and Latinx masculine expression will continue to create complications for youth identity development within these respective communities. Additionally, both Black and Latinx communities maintain expressions specific to their respective cultures while existing under the gaze of oppressive groups.
The intersection of race and gender across societal institutions creates an environment where both racial and gendered stereotypes exist, are enforced, and are intertwined. Thus, forcing those with intersecting identities to navigate confusing, rigid periods where their actions and beliefs are often condemned. This juggling act manifests a fractured self-image, which acutely impacts individuals as they develop their social identity. By acknowledging the convergence of biases, intersectionality exposes the intricate avenues through which social discrimination exists within societal institutions. Within societal institutions, intersectionality allows one to assess how discrimination acts as a long-standing power struggle that disrupts the development of oppressed groups within society. While such institutions have the ability to foster equity within communal organization, they often cultivate discrimination by upholding rigid and contradictory values.
In conclusion, Intersectionality should always be used to address and examine the violence perpetrated through institutional norms and practices, as this framework emphasizes how social identities converge to affect social experiences. In this way, one can begin to address how specific groups are repeatedly discriminated against within the criminal justice system because of their unique and intersecting identity. This strong difference between the expectation of the institutions, and the day-to-day realities for marginalized communities, requires examining how masculine identity is formed alongside racial identity. Assessing intersectionality within the criminal justice system illustrates how an individual should not use gender or race alone to make sense of their lived reality. Rather, they should consider how the intersection of multiple identities influences their individual experience. Intersectionality acknowledges the unique combination of social identity, and how one’s identity is influenced by societal structures, such as the criminal justice system. Understanding and achieving equity, in any real sense, requires a departure from these rigid norms instituted by society’s structures.
Works Cited:
1. Kang, Miliann, et al. “Intersectionality.” Introduction to Women Gender Sexuality Studies, University of Massachusetts Amherst Libraries, 30 June 2017,
openbooks.library.umass.edu/introwgss/chapter/intersectionality/.
2. Ibid. Kang, Miliann, et al. “Intersectionality.”
3. Rios, V. M. (2009). The Consequences of the Criminal Justice Pipeline on Black and Latino Masculinity. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 623, 150–162. http://www.jstor.org/stable/40375893
4. Ibid. Rios, V. M. (2009).